Over the trenches once more
I actually went to University for the first time at the age of 36. After a number of years at home raising our children we were finding it more difficult to make ends meet, and so I tried to re-enter the work force. Doors shut in my face. It was made too obvious that they considered that my brain could only have solidified and my skills all but vanished. So I applied to University and was accepted.
The first literature assignment I handed in came back with a mark of 12 out of 20. I stood in my lecturer’s office and cried because I thought I was never going to make it. Obviously I was stupid and was never going make it to ever graduate. Right in that moment it was all or nothing to me. This one setback, a low mark, was enough to jump start my defeatist mind set and have me on the verge of running all the way back to my home sweet home.
However, I was able to muster the right or more positive responses to allow me to continue and even to flourish at University. I managed a credit for that unit in the first semester, and a High Distinction for following.
A friend had a similar experience when she embarked on journalism studies. One of the lecturers was an abrasive man who worked the students hard. Each week he made them do a general knowledge test and would be dismissive of anyone who would fail. His real method was to make the students aware that journalism was in fact a nasty business and you had to be tough to make it. If not there was the door. She ran for that door as fast as she could and for the past 15 years has blamed the lecturer for her “career loss”. She did go back to university but chose a course that had little hope of actually leading to a real career in Australia. She has worked in food service or retail every since.
So why did she default to helplessness so readily? She appeared not to be able to see that everything was not all or nothing. There is more than one way open to us. I assessed my options and decided that I had to work smarter, she looked around and decided there were no options for her except to run away. Passivity, fear and depression have ruled her life ever since.
My friend decided that she wouldn’t just give up on this specific battle but with the tape on repeat in her head continually, she embraced the decision to capitulate on every issue. This feeling of helplessness that she took as her mantel has allowed her to shun real responsibility for choices and the frustrations she experiences continuously. My friend blames fate, circumstances and particularly other people for what befalls her. Somehow she never mobilized her own energy to overcome roadblocks to her goals.
How has she done this? She makes long lists of the negatives or disadvantages. Catastrophe thinking. I never hear her speak of positives. No little train that thinks it can. All defeats are so serious that she rehashes them continuously. Years after the fact, she is still generalizing it to her entire existence.
Why can I see these tendencies in her and she can’t see them herself? She willingly gives into them but never stops to think why is it so? Her frustrations bring her down and she sees all defeats as permanent and long term. She lives an immobilized life always waiting for the next hit which of course does come because she sets herself up in the crosshairs every time. She surrenders before the first shot, when she perhaps should be singing I think I can, I think I can as she goes over the top of the trenches.
Comments
I have had to work at not seeing life through the same lenses as your friend. It can be so easy to become defeatist about yourself and your options when things don't go as planned. Over time, I am learning to be more of a "bright side" person who tries not to give up, and I'm getting better.
And even though I went to college as a "traditional" student at 18, fresh out of high school, I had a similar experience to yours. My high school didn't have many students who were interested in college at all, and there wasn't a real push for it back then. My English and writing teachers loved finding students who were actually interested in what they were teaching, so in me, they found someone to encourage and support. I got to college thinking I was the next great novelist because of all the praise and encouragement I'd received along the way. In my first creative writing class, I got a B- on my first assignment, dissolved into tears, and thought about changing my major to psychology.
That prof ended up being one of the best writing mentors I've ever had, and we're still friends today.
GOOD post! This is such a good reminder of what we should all be like. Unfortunately, there are so many people like your friend. I have a friend like that too. She's SO smart and she's gone nowhere with her life. Her problem is that she thinks that if she can't be 100% perfect at everything, why even try. Maybe that's your friends problem too?
Anyway, CONGRATS for being such a trooper and carrying on, even when it looked like you weren't off to a great start. You're an inspiration!
Oh, FD, such a good post. I think ALL of us know people like this in our lives, and you're always sad because YOU see the lost potential in that person(s). You also get tired of scraping them off the pavement in every "defeat" and consoling them when they lack the ability to perservere at anything.
It rocks that you did not let one bad experience define your academic/career progression. It is so very hard not to be crushed when you're raw and insecure at the beginning of a journey. My entry back into academia at 26 was excruciating. I had a severe phobia about entering the classroom again after a five year hiatus. I had heart palpitations, sweaty palms, and I would writhe in my chair that first quarter trying to go unnoticed by the instructor. But she did notice me, and she called on me quite often. I'm so very glad she did. She became my mentor and before she died of lung cancer (six months before I graduated), she became my thesis advisor. Amazing woman, and I think it taught me that you NEVER know where a good life lesson is going to come from :)
That was inspring. I am an Admissions Advisor at an online university, and I know many of my students work through these fears all of the time. Reading your post helped me to put myself in their shoes and do my job better.
There are areas of my life where I am guilty of "Stinking Thinking". Your post helped me put that in check.
Thanks for writing that. It really did remind me of my friend. On the other hand, that's not all there is about a person, even with the depression and self-esteem issues. Fortunately, there are generous portions of good things, too.
You are very insightful. I am frustrated by my friend who is very intelligent and has just languished through her life. The funny thing is though that she also thinks she is superior to most people around her. I guess by not actually reaching for th stars she can't be proved wrong! Some days her negativity just about brings me to my knees but on the other hand she is so loyal , so generous and has such a heart of gold one can't leave her! I just wish more, better, happier for her.